My Big Fat Gypsy Fistfight

Most Popular

“Knuckle”, a new documentary about an age-old feud between two traveller families, is not by any stretch a polished film. In fact, it’s not even a particularly gripping film. Structured around a decade of repetitively bleak bare-knuckle dust-ups between the Quinn McDonaghs and the Joyces, who slug it out in muddy car parks and country lanes from Oxford to Dundalk, trying to determine once and for all - well, no one quite remembers what.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Certainly there was a bar brawl in the early Nineties after which “Curly” Paddy Quinn McDonagh served time for the manslaughter of Brian Joyce. The enmity between the two families – many of whom, due to the insularity of traveller communities, are related – existed before that and, you suspect, will continue long after Curly Paddy has joined Brian in the sod.

But for all its lack of narrative arc, where “Knuckle” packs a punch is in what it tells us about men, violence, and the inanity of an eye-for-an-eye justice for which there can be no end.  “Knuckle” hints at the bigger story: that this isn’t about individual grievances, it’s about fuelling a sense of forward momentum – giving your clan a need to be bigger, stronger and tougher, when simply surviving is no longer a concern. It justifies barrel-chested grandfathers bloodying each other’s whiskered mouths. It justifies skin headed boys shadow-boxing each other with uncomprehending delight. And it justifies grown men making low-grade videos of themselves wearing Eighties leather jackets, lifting dumbbells made of bricks, and calling their neighbours a “cowardly pack of bollocks”. And so the world turns. Knuckle is out  on DVD now.

Most Popular

We're giving away 3 copies, head over our Facebook Page to enter the competition.

A more eloquent take on the punch-up

While we’re on the subject of men beating the bejesus out of each other, allow us to bring your attention to Townie: A Memoir by Andre Dubus III, author of House of Sand and Fog. It’s a lyrical and frank account of how, in a downbeat Massachusetts town in the Seventies, the author’s adolescent urge to become tough enough to protect himself and his family turned into something else: a need to fight for the sake of fighting, to turn another man’s face “bone-white, his lower face wet and red, his mouth a dark hole”, just because he could. Brooding, brutal and strangely beautiful. Townie: A Memoir (Norton) by Andre Dubus III is out now.

 

What do you think?

Culture
Share
5 Things Every Man Needs To Know About This Week
​Your cultural(ish) guide to the week ahead​​
TV
Share
Game of Thrones Actors are Also Peeved About Their Characters Randomly Getting Killed
The man behind Doran Martell opens up about his one big moment last season
Culture
Share
This Is Where "Roger That" Really Comes From
​Copy that.​
Culture
Share
Man Who Lived As A Goat For Three Days Wins A (Spoof) Nobel Prize
​​Wait, what?​
iPhone 7
Culture
Share
This Is How Much It Actually Costs Apple To Make An iPhone 7
There's a reason they're worth $624 billion​​
Lego drone
Culture
Share
You Can Now Build Drones With LEGO, If That's The Kind Of Thing You're Into
Finally, technology we can get on board with​​
TV
Share
Why The New 'Westworld' Matters
The new version comes out on HBO soon, and the 1973 original is still shaping sci-fi
Mourinho and Wenger
Culture
Share
Jose Mourinho 'Wanted To Break' Arsene Wenger's Face Over Mata Transfer
According to a new book​
Culture
Share
Edward Snowden Just Named An App That You Should Avoid At All Costs
​Google 'Allo' is "surveillance", apparently​
Culture
Share
Count Dracula's Castle Is Up For Sale
​Deep in the Romanian countryside, this towering 12th century fortress inspired Bram Stoker's 1897 novel​