5 Cowboy And Indian Myths Debunked, By The Author Of 'The Son'

Most Popular

Philipp Meyer's great new novel The Son confronts myths of the American West. 

Here, he shoots down five of the biggest lies you were told about 'cowboys and Indians' .

MYTH #1 Cowboys fought Indians
While this happened, it was rare. By 1865, when the big cattle drives began, the Plains Indians had already been decimated. Also, the big cattle trails intentionally cut a wide swath around hostile Native AmericansÕ territories. So, who fought the Native Americans? Whoever lived on the frontier. The settlers were poor, a little desperate, and knowingly making their home on land occupied by Native Americans for about 15,000 years. 

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

MYTH #2 The cowboy was the great rugged individualist of his time 
The rugged individualists of the day were the explorers, trappers and mountain men who walked and rode into areas no European had ever seen, living on and navigating land for which there were no maps. Picture a very smart but very smelly man dressed in animal skins, carrying a Bowie knife and a flintlock rifle. The cowboy, by comparison, was a civilised creature Ñ closer to a truck driver Ñ escorting a high value cargo across a known, well-mapped route.

Most Popular

MYTH #3 The cowboy played a major role in American history
The long cattle drives, which employed the vast number of cowboys, were from about 1866Ð86. The main job of a cowboy was to drive cattle to the closest railroad hub. By the mid-1880s, extensive railroad networks put an end to the long cattle drives, which were a temporary business opportunity. The cowboy played only the briefest of roles in American history, before the farmers and settlers came in.

MYTH #4 Cowboys died in gunfights
More cowboys were killed by falls and lightning than by bullets. No matter what the weather, the cowboy had to be out riding circles around cattle to hold the herd in place. Men often rode off cliffs in the dark or, if thrown off a horse, could be trampled by cattle. A cowboy carried a gun or two, but if he ever drew it on a person, it was probably on a farmer whoÕd erected a fence across a cattle trail.

MYTH #5 A cowboy's life was exciting
In fact, it was generally slow, boring, dusty work. The cowboy slept in rain, sleet and snow under a single wool blanket. He was always either too hot or too cold, riding in a cloud of dust kicked up thousands of cattle (unlike in the movies, cattle herds were driven at the slowest of walks to stop them losing weight and reducing their sale price). With only a few hours sleep a night, the cowboy generally arrived at his destination exhausted, filthy and saddlesore.

The Son by Philipp Meyer, is out 18 July, Simon & Schuster

What do you think?

Lil Wayne
Culture
Share
Lil' Wayne Officiated A Same-Sex Wedding While In Prison
​​As you do ​
Sam Allardyce
Culture
Share
Sam Allardyce Embarrasses The FA And Himself After Being Caught In Newspaper Sting
Why, Sam? Why?​​
Matt LeBlanc in Top Gear
TV
Share
Matt LeBlanc Signs Up For Another Two Series Of Top Gear
How you doin'? Pretty good actually​
Film
Share
Now Liev Schreiber And Naomi Watts Have Split Up
Tough times in Hollywood​
Film
Share
Turns Out Lupita Nyong'o Is A Pretty Awesome Rapper
​​The Oscar-winning actress heralds her latest social media milestone​
Tom Hanks wedding photo bomb
Film
Share
Tom Hanks Photobombs A Couple's Wedding Photographs, Because Of Course He Did
Life is like a box of chocolates after all​
Culture
Share
Angelina Jolie And Brad Pitt Reportedly Have An 'Ironclad' Prenup
​Here's how they'll split $500 Million
Film
Share
Michael Bay Defends Covering Churchill's Birthplace In Nazi Flags. Says He Would "Smile" About It
Michael Bay is almost certainly wrong​
Culture
Share
Arnold Palmer: What I've Learned
​The then 82-year-old golfer on how staying with the classic styles helped him dress well his whole life​
In order to hide his Polio from the public, Franklin D. Roosevelt arrived in New York via a secret extension of Grand Central Terminal underneath the Waldorf Astoria hotel. His abandoned train car—which is still there today—transported the president and his limousine directly up into the hotel's garage so he could come and go unnoticed.
Culture
Share
17 Photos Of The Most Eerie Abandoned Sites In The World
And in some cases, actually haunted