Annual best-dressed lists often make little sense. That's because a whole lot of backroom politicking and planning go into them. So Esquire is once again asking you, dear reader, to decide upon our Best-Dressed Man of the Year. Last week, Tom Hiddleston scored a place in the semi-finals over Jake Gyllenhaal. And so it's onto the next: Idris Elba vs. Sebastian Stan.


Note: voting is now closed

You can be a stylish man without shouting about it. In fact, style – real, proper style – is about knowing what works for you, then playing with the formula ever so slightly. Enter two men who live that rule to the letter, this week's Style Trials contenders: Idris Elba and Sebastian Stan.

For the former, it's a tried-and-tested uniform that always works: the occasional red beanie, simple T-shirts that are kind to his guns, and a go-to pair of fail-safe Wayfarers. So far, so staple. When Elba does need to soup things up though, he goes à la carte. See this year's Met Gala 'fit, a rococo-meets-rave fluoro-tinged dinner jacket.

idris elba
Getty Images

Which is an approach echoed by Sebastian Stan. However, the Marvel star loves to play around with volume. We've seen some really, really wide trousers, in a safe shade of navy. We've seen splashes of mustard on a monochrome base. And we've seen suits in rust and forest green, which were well-paired with quieter pieces below.

sebastian stan
Getty Images

So, who gets your vote? The man that pops on the odd occasion, or the man who's always taking a quiet risk?

idris elba sebastian stan
Ana Davila